Home

About Us

Membership

AGM Minutes

 

 
 

MSA Home > Publications > Newsletter 52

Newsletter 52 (February 2000)
ISSN 0155-0543
GPO Box 2404 Canberra ACT 2601 Website: www.msa.org.au
E-mail: jphil@chariot.net.au

National Committee 1998-1999: President: Craig De Wilde (Vic) Secretary: John A. Phillips (SA) Treasurer: Jula Szuster (SA)
Past President: Stephen Wild (ACT) Ex officio IMS: Margaret Kartomi (Vic) Ex Officio ICTM: Allan Marett (Syd)
Committee Members: Kimi Coaldrake (SA) Anne-Marie Forbes (Qld/Tas) Royston Gustavson (Vic) Elizabeth MacKinlay (Qld) Jennie Shaw (Sydney) David Symons (WA) Shirley Trembath (Qld)
Membership Secretary: Daniela Kaleva Dept. of Music, Monash University Clayton VIC 3168 E-mail: dkaleva@hotmail.com
Editor, Musicology Australia Volume XXIII (2000): Paul Watt 57 Forster Street Heidelberg VIC 3081 E-mail: pwatt@cup.edu.au

Website Coordinator: Brett Chapman 144 Bellevue Avenue Rosanna VIC 3084 E-mail: Brett.Chapman@riotinto.com


Closing date for Newsletter contributions:
No. 53 September 2000 edition by FRIDAY 25 AUGUST 2000

Editor, Newsletter:
John A. Phillips
1209 Lower North East Road
Highbury SA 5089
Ph./Fax: (08) 8395 5332
E-mail: jphil@chariot.net.au

Thanks to all contributors and to KwikKopy Unley, SA, for their assistance in the printing of this issue.


CONTENTS
1999 Annual General Meeting  Minutes
President's Message
Secretary's Report
Treasurer's Report
'Wagga Wagga Weekend Weekend' Report
Chapter Reports:
ACT
Queensland
South Australia
Sydney
Victoria
Musicology Australia, vol. 23 (2000)
Update on the MSA website
Conference Reports:
35th ICTM World Conference
Graduate Music Symposium '99
Forthcoming Conferences:
Sydney 2000 (Program & Report)
One-Day Conference, Melbourne
Newcastle Study Weekend Melbourne 2000
Preliminary Call For Papers For MSA Conference 2001
19th-Century Music, London
ISFNR Conference, Melbourne
Music's Audience: Reading and Listening to Music in Australia and England, 1880-1930
Miscellaneous Notices
Register of Graduate Theses in Music
Submissions to Registers
Register of Graduate Theses-in-Progress
MSA: Notification of Thesis-in-Progress


Musicological Society of Australia Incorporated
- 1999 ANNUAL GENERAL MEETING -
Held at the Riverine Club, Wagga Wagga,
Sunday 12 September 1999, at 1.50 pm
  
 

Top of Page

Tabled:
A: Agenda
B: Minutes of last AGM, 29 Nov. 1998 (as circulated in Newsletter No. 50,
February 1999)
C. Secretary's Report: Membership Tables
D: Financial report on MSA

Craig De Wilde, Society President, welcomed members to the meeting and announced that the ballot for the election of officers to the National Committee and the referendum on proposed amendments to the Society's constitution would close at 2.00 pm. Michael Christoforidis and Carol Williams were appointed as returning officers.

Present: Roland Bannister, Michael Christoforidis, Craig De Wilde, Christopher Draber, Elizabeth Kertesz, Ian MacDonald, Allan Marett, Prue Neidorf, John Phillips, Jennie Shaw, Jula Szuster, Stephen Wild, Carol Williams.

1. Apologies

Apologies were received from: Bronwen Arthur, Peter Campbell, Kimi Coaldrake, Anne-Marie Forbes, Royston Gustavson, Hazel Hall, Robyn Holmes, Daniela Kaleva, Jaki Kane, Margaret Kartomi, Hans Kuhn, Elizabeth MacKinlay, Kerry Murphy, Peter Platt, Victoria Rogers, Aline Scott-Maxwell, Jan Stockigt, David Symons, Shirley Trembath, Christopher Wainwright, Paul Watt, John Whiteoak, Lewis Wickes.

2. Confirmation of the Minutes of the Annual General Meeting, 29 Nov. 1998

It was moved that: The minutes of the meeting circulated to members in the MSA Newsletter No.50, February 1999, be accepted as a true and accurate record of that meeting.
Moved: Stephen Wild Seconded: Jula Szuster Carried

3. Matters arising from the Minutes of the 1998 Annual General Meeting

3.1 2000 Conference
Discussion of the 2000 conference was deferred to item 5.2.
4. Reports

4.1 President's Report
Society President, Craig De Wilde, read his report. Copies were distributed to members present at the meeting.
It was moved that: The President's Report be accepted.
Moved: Prue Neidorf Seconded: Allan Marett Carried

4.2 Secretary's Report
The National Secretary, John Phillips, read his report to the meeting. Table 1 (Society Membership as at September 1999) and Table 2 (Seven-year Summary of Individual Membership by Chapter) were circulated to members present.
It was moved that: The Secretary's Report be accepted.
Moved: Stephen Wild Seconded: Jula Szuster Carried

Stephen Wild asked that it be noted that the ACT Chapter of the Society had recently elected a new Executive and was once again active.

4.3 Treasurer's Report
The National Treasurer, Jula Szuster, read her report to the meeting. The financial report prepared by the Society's auditor and the treasurer's report from the 1998 MSA National Conference were distributed to members present.
It was moved that: The Treasurer's Report be accepted.
Moved: John Phillips Seconded: Jennie Shaw Carried

Jula explained that the Society's current liabilities consisted of a number of unpresented cheques. Now that the ACT Chapter was again financial, some of the cheques would be presented and cleared promptly. Others, particularly those dating from the 1995-1996 tax year, would be further investigated and cancelled if appropriate.
Discussion followed concerning the Society's investments. It was noted that the Society's finances are in a healthy state and that the ANZ V2 Plus Account, which the Executive opened in March 1999, had already generated a reasonable amount of interest.
It was moved that: An additional $6,000.00 be transferred from the Society's ANZ Bank Access Account to the Society's ANZ V2 Plus Account.
Moved: Roland Bannister Seconded: Stephen Wild Carried

Jula explained that the auditor had commended the Society on the quality of its financial records and had suggested some minor improvements to assist in the audit process. The auditor had also recommended that the Society seek advice on the impact of the G.S.T.

4.4 Journal Editor's Report
The report prepared by Editor Sandra McColl was read by John Phillips.
It was moved that: The Journal Editor's Report be accepted.
Moved: Stephen Wild Seconded: Jula Szuster Carried

Discussion followed concerning the onerous task of editing the Society's Journal and the difficulties encountered by the National Committee in its attempts to find an editor to replace Sandra. The Executive was very pleased that, commencing with volume 23 of the Journal, Paul Watt, current Assistant Editor of the Journal, had agreed to take over as Journal Editor. Sandra had agreed to serve as Assistant Editor. The National Committee had decided to offer the position of Journal Editor to Paul for a period of three years and that of Assistant Editor to Sandra for one year. This would ease the transition and give the Executive time to find a replacement Assistant Editor.

4.5 Newsletter Editor's Report
Newsletter Editor, John Phillips, read his report to the meeting.
It was moved that: The Newsletter Editor's Report be accepted.
Moved: Allan Marett Seconded: Christopher Draber Carried

In response to a question asked by Stephen Wild, John explained that Institutional Members can elect whether or not to receive the Society's Newsletters. Responses so far had been mixed: some Institutional Members had requested both Newsletters Nos. 49 and 50; others had chosen not to receive any Newsletters.

4.6 International Council for Traditional Music (ICTM) Report
Allan Marett explained that the MSA has been a member of ICTM since 1988 and first held a joint conference with it in 1995. Allan emphasised the importance of keeping both organisations aware of each other's activities. He also suggested that the MSA and ICTM should consider the possibility of holding joint conference events.
Allan commented on the success of the 35th ICTM World Conference, which was held 19-25 August 1999 in Hiroshima. It attracted approximately 270 participants, about half of whom were Japanese. The conference appeared to mark a watershed for Japanese musicologists and ethnomusicologists. Eleven Australians participated and MSA members Linda Barwick, Allan Marett and Stephen Wild had presented a plenary session on Music and Reconciliation.
It was noted that Stephen Wild had been elected Chair of the Oceania Study Group of the ICTM and that Allan had been appointed coordinator of the ICTM Colloquia. Allan suggested that MSA members might suggest themes for the colloquia, which are usually presented by invited participants (guidelines available from Allan). He also asked members to note that the ICTM World Conference in 2001 is scheduled to take place in Rio de Janeiro.
Stephen Wild noted that, to celebrate its move, AIATSIS was planning a major conference in September 2001, which Stephen would be convening. The ICTM Oceania Study Group had been invited to meet with AIATSIS in Canberra at the same time (September 19, 2000).
It was moved that: The National Committee of the ICTM, on behalf of the MSA, co-host the ICTM Oceania Study Group's meeting.
Moved: Stephen Wild Seconded: Allan Marett Carried

5. Conferences

5.1 MSA 22nd National Conference (Perth, 1999), Interim Report
On behalf of conference convenors David Symons and David Tunley, Jula Szuster presented the interim report on the Society's 1999 Perth conference to the meeting. It was noted that, with the generous assistance of an anonymous donor, all expenses, including the conference excursion to New Norcia, had been covered and a profit of approximately $2336 was expected.

5.2 Update on the 23rd National Conference (Sydney, 2000)
Conference convenor Allan Marett spoke about the planning of the Society's 23rd National Conference, which is to be held in Sydney from 27-30 April, 2000. He explained that the meeting was to be held jointly with the 17th Annual Conference of the New Zealand Musicological Society (NZMS). The conference venue, the Seymour Centre at the University of Sydney, had been secured and a range of accommodation had been identified, with prices ranges of $25-60 for Youth Hostel and YWCA and $95-140 for hotel accommodation.
The main theme, 'Music as Cultural Interpretation', was intended to be inclusive, not exclusive, and had been divided into three sub themes: Cultural Interpretations of Music, The Contribution of Musicology to the Study of Popular Music, and Research in Indigenous Performance: Current Issues. Paper proposals outside these areas would also be considered.
Allan also asked the Society to note that Warren Drake, President of the NZMS, had been approached when these themes were initially formulated and that 'indigenous music' was intended to include Australian, New Zealand and any other indigenous musics. The conference committee was also grateful to the NZMS for proposing William Dart, musicologist and editor of the NZMS Journal, as one of the conference's keynote speakers. Other invited keynote speakers were Robert Walser and Susan McClary. Professor McClary had been invited to give the inaugural Alfred Hook Memorial Lecture for the University of Sydney Department of Music, which would be funding her visit. Stanley Sadie, who, due to a serious car accident, had been unable to attend the 1999 Perth conference as keynote speaker, had been invited to present a paper in a session dedicated to music encyclopaedias and the establishment of the canon. The conference committee was also planning to have a two-and-a-half hour plenary session on indigenous music which would be followed by discussion and then shorter sessions for individual papers. Allan proposed that the Saturday of the conference should be dedicated to the theme 'Research in Indigenous Performance: Current Issues' and be jointly sponsored by the MSA, NZMS, ICTM and the Research Institute for the Humanities and Social Sciences at Sydney University. It was hope that scholars from other disciplines such as anthropology, linguistics and performance studies would also attend. Stephen Wild suggested that AIATSIS should also be invited to participate.
Brief discussion followed concerning the conference dinner, the venue and cost of which remain to be fixed. Allan explained that a conference brochure would be mailed to members in mid-late October with further details.

5.3 AGM for 2000
Craig De Wilde noted that the Society's next Annual General Meeting would have to be held after 30 June 2000 to allow sufficient time for the financial records to be audited. If the Newcastle Chapter was operational by then, they might be willing to host the meeting. Craig would follow this through with Michael Ewans. Stephen Wild also suggested that the Canberra Chapter would be willing to host the AGM if Newcastle was not able to do so. In any case, given the Sydney Olympics, the AGM should probably be held in late November to allow as many members as possible to attend and participate in a study weekend similar to the 1999 Wagga Wagga Weekend.

5.4 MSA 24th National Conference, 2001
It was reported to the meeting that the Melbourne Chapter of the Society had expressed interest in hosting the Society's national conference in 2001. It was noted that Melbourne had last hosted the national conference in 1996. It was also noted that it would be desirable to have the meeting later in the year so that the Society's AGM could be held at the same time, although a clash with the AIATSIS meeting in September should be avoided.
It was moved that: The Society accept the invitation of the Melbourne Chapter to host the conference and that Kerry Murphy be nominated as convenor, subject to her acceptance.
Moved: Allan Marett Seconded: Prue Neidorf Carried

6. Website initiatives

John Phillips referred members to the Website Report in the Society's Newsletter No. 51. A detailed description of work completed on the Society's website and of initiatives proposed for the site was distributed to members present. John remarked on the urgent need for the National Committee to appoint a Website Coordinator.
It was moved that: The MSA offer to provide training to an MSA member who would then act as inaugural Website Coordinator for a period of not less than two years.
Moved: Elizabeth Kertesz Seconded: Jula Szuster Carried

7. Motions of Appreciation

Craig De Wilde proposed a motion of thanks to Roland Bannister for his smooth organisation of a very worthwhile and enjoyable Wagga Wagga study weekend. Roland proposed a motion of thanks to Isabel Reid, elder of the Wiradjuri people, for her welcome to Society members and the Dindimar Dancers, Dane Simpson and Eddie Whyman, for their welcoming performance. On behalf of the meeting, Roland also thanked Major Patrick Pickett, Director of the Riverina Conservatorium, for officially opening the study weekend and the Riverine Club for hosting the Society's Conversations and AGM.
Craig proposed a motion of thanks to David Tunley, David Symons, Victoria Rogers, Patricia Thorpe, Jan Wood and the University of Western Australia for their management of the very successful 1999 national conference in Perth. On behalf of the meeting, he also thanked the Journal and Newsletter editors and members of the National Committee for their hard work. Stephen Wild thanked Jennie Shaw for serving as National Treasurer until her move overseas in March 1999 and, on behalf of the Society's members, thanked the current Executive, Craig De Wilde, John Phillips and Jula Szuster, for their dedication to the society.
All these motions were carried unanimously by the meeting.

8. Election of Executive and National Committee Members

The Musicological Society of Australia's 1999-2000 Executive and National Committee were announced as follows:

President: Craig De Wilde
Secretary: John Phillips
Treasurer: Jula Szuster

Committee: Kimi Coaldrake, Anne-Marie Forbes, Royston Gustavson, Elizabeth MacKinlay, Jennie Shaw,
David Symons, Shirley Trembath.

9. Referendum on Constitutional Amendments

The returning officers explained that 61 votes had been received, of which 58 were valid. Six of the seven proposed amendments to the Society's constitution were carried.
It was moved that: The voting numbers on each constitutional amendment be made public to members.
Moved: Jennie Shaw Seconded: Stephen Wild
Result: 11 in favour of the motion, 2 against Carried

The proposed amendments and results of the ballot were as follows:

1. "The name of the incorporated association shall be The Australian Society for Music Research Incorporated …"
Result: 27 in favour, 31 against Not Carried

2. "Membership fees and any Chapter levies are payable … on 1 July each year."
Result: 58 in favour Carried

3. Inclusion of position of Membership Secretary in MSA National Committee.
Result: 55 in favour, 3 against Carried

4. Duties incumbent upon the Membership Secretary.
Result: 58 in favour Carried

5. Option of members being able to run for executive positions as teams.
Result: 58 in favour Carried

6. "Indigenous custodians will be recognised at the principal place of all National MSA public events in a manner appropriate to MSA and to those custodians."
Result: 51 in favour, 7 against Carried

7. "The official year of the MSA shall be from 1 July to the 30 June..."
Result: 58 in favour Carried

There was a vote of thanks for the two returning officers.

10. Other Business Arising

Prue Neidorf asked that the Society consider supporting the submission made to the National Library by the International Association of Music Libraries, Archives and Documentation (IAML) for a Music Specialist Reference Librarian to be appointed to the National Library. Prue read a draft of IAML's submission to members present. It was noted that the position had been vacant since 1994 and that, without the assistance and knowledge of a Music Specialist Reference Librarian, it was difficult for musicians and music researchers to access and use the National Library's music collections.
It was moved that: The MSA President write to the National Library in support of the IAML submission.
Moved: Jula Szuster Seconded: Michael Christoforidis Carried

The meeting was declared closed at 4.00 pm.
Minutes ratified at the 2000 AGM, 12 November 2000

John Phillips, National Secretary
Jennie Shaw, National Committee
 

Top of Page

PRESIDENT'S MESSAGE

This is one of the few addresses you will likely hear this year that will not evoke a provocative reference to the upcoming millennium, nor will it enter into the debate that the true beginning of the next century is a bit over fifteen months, not three months, away. Nevertheless, to say that the discipline of musicology is facing yet another crossroads in its journey is not overstating the fact. All that one need do is to look at our sister organisations in other countries.

The American Musicological Society, for example, has had a long running and, at times, very contentious debate regarding the state of the discipline, the often puzzling rivalry between the so-called "old" musicology and the "new" musicology, and the comment that these issues are ultimately dulling the critical edge of new scholarship. Yet I cannot help but be optimistic with the Australian situation in this regard. The scope and variety of papers presented at the 22nd National Conference of the Society in Perth this past July, with the theme Research and Music Performance, is a testimony to the innovative and significant research being undertaken by this Society's membership, and I see it as very much a sharpening of this critical edge. In addition, while some might think me overly optimistic, I am cautiously hopeful that we are now on the recovery side of the recent devastating upheavals in arts faculties and music schools and departments in universities throughout Australia. As I see it at this juncture, we have two options: we can either lament our losses and pine for the way things used to be, complaining that the rising "Telstra-isation" of our universities is placing our research on the margins, or we can look to ways of illustrating the importance and relevance of our work from perspectives outside solely financial ones. It is only through the latter that we can begin to get back to the work at hand, rather than worry if we have a job to get back to in the first place, or have any hope of finding work in the discipline in Australian universities in the future for those who want it. It is the responsibility of academic societies such as this one to illustrate the relevance of our research and make our work accessible to a broad range of interests. There is no question that we are not out of the woods yet, but from my perspective the signs are far more encouraging than they were this time last year.


The Executive Committee thus far, besides dealing with the day-to-day matters of the running of the Society, has begun in earnest to address some of the issues as set out in the Draft Strategic Plan developed by the Long Range Planning Committee in 1997-1998. One major achievement to date has been the phase one revision and expansion of the Society's Internet website. The new site now includes extensive information about the Society, including copies of Newsletters numbers 49, 50, and 51, membership information, and conference information and activities. In addition, the site is now indexed with the major Internet search engines. Another recent achievement is the updating, development and design of a new membership brochure. Special thanks must go to John Phillips for his ever-tireless work in arranging and organising both these efforts, and to Anne Marie Forbes in her work with the wording for the brochure. At this meeting, we will be voting on several constitutional issues which will have an impact on the future direction of the Society as well.


The first issue of the Newsletter (No. 50) for 1999 was distributed in late February, and the second issue (No. 51) was distributed in early August, with both issues very ably edited by John Phillips. As always, the Newsletter relies heavily on timely contributions from members, so please forward any and all relevant items about yourselves, chapter activities, and any other information which might be of interest to other members. Musicology Australia, volume 12 (1998) was distributed to all financial individual and institutional members by early June of this year. Sandra McColl currently is editing her final volume (volume 22, 1999) after which her term as editor will end. For volume 23 (2000) the current assistant editor of MA, Paul Watt, has agreed to assume the editorship while Sandra moves into the assistant editor position. I'm certain you will all agree that the resulting journal does the Society proud, and join me in not only congratulating and thanking Sandra for her fine work as editor for the past four years, but also in wishing Paul well in his new duties. Your support of MA, especially with your contributions, will continue to maintain this high standard.


The 1998 National Conference at the University of Adelaide, immediately following the Wagner Symposium, proved to be an extremely successful event. The participation of members was excellent, with several outstanding papers as well as some delightful social activities, including a wonderful conference dinner at Charlick's Feed Store Restaurant. Many thanks go to the convenor Jula Szuster and her extremely able and hard-working staff to make this event a glowing success.
The 1999 National Conference at the University of Western Australia in Perth was a flawless organised event by which future conferences will be measured. Even the weather cooperated with glorious clear and warm days, reserving the torrential downpour to begin only at the close of the Special General Meeting on the Sunday. The theme, "Research and Music Perform-ance", combining the ideas of the historical and theoretical with the practical, was particularly significant in light of recent developments in the discipline, and the three keynote addresses and many excellent papers displayed a very broad interpretation of this theme. I'm sure you join me in congratulating the "two Davids", David Tunley and David Symons, for their outstanding work as co-convenors, and gratefully acknowledge their staff on a job very well done.


The current Wagga Wagga Weekend Weekend already promises to be a very fruitful study weekend at the time of this writing. Instead of the traditional paper-giving sessions, Roland Bannister has organised this study weekend to discuss issues regarding current music research projects and their relevance in various contexts, which is precisely what this Society needs to do in order to confirm an influential place for music research in a changing academic and social environment.
The 2000 National Conference will be held at the University of Sydney from Thursday 27 to Sunday 30 April. This conference will be a joint event with the Musicological Society of New Zealand. The convenor, Allan Marett, has organised the theme of "Music as Cultural Interpretation", looking in particular at this area as well as the contribution of musicology to the study of popular music and current issues regarding research in indigenous performance. Further arrangements, including proposed keynote speakers and various planned performances, will be reported upon later in this meeting.


I would firstly like to express my profound gratitude to my Executive Committee: John Phillips, Jennie Shaw and Jula Szuster. Anyone who has ever assumed the executive leadership of an organisation such as this (and I know there are several in this room) are well aware of the time and commitment required in its operation. There is absolutely no doubt that this organisation is greatly indebted to these individuals. John, as National Secretary, has been nothing short of brilliant with the amount of time, insight, and attention to detail he brings to this position, particularly with his work revising the website, editing the Newsletters, and organising the myriad of administrative matters. He is also one of the few people I know who writes more frequent and more extensive email messages than I do! Jennie's initial work as National Treasurer, which has now been selflessly assumed by Jula since Jennie's departure to Japan, has also been outstanding in dealing with the very large amount of correspondence and other financial duties required on a regular basis. Special thanks must also be extended to Kimi Coaldrake for arranging the teleconferences of the Executive Committee between myself in Melbourne and the others in Adelaide, and then proceeding to disrupt her work schedule while her office is occupied. I also wish to thank Daniela Kaleva who at my request has been acting as Membership Secretary to assist in all matters related to updating addresses and mailing lists.


Thanks, of course, to Sandra McColl for her excellent editing of the Society's journal over the past four years, and to Paul Watt for his professional editing assistance during this time as well as assuming the Editorship beginning with the 2000 edition. The journal is another extremely onerous task, which both these individuals accomplish with grace and efficiency. Thanks to the National Com-mittee and associated members (Kimi Coaldrake, Annie-Marie Forbes, Royston Gustavson, Robyn Holmes, Elizabeth MacKinlay, Shirley Trembath, Jennie Shaw, David Symons, Stephen Wild, Margaret Kartomi, and Allan Marett) for their contributions and support to the Society, and to the Editorial Advisory Committee for their tireless work with the journal. Finally, my profound and sincere thanks to all of you, the members. It is through your support, your guidance, and your contributions that makes my job as President both enjoyable and gratifying.


Craig De Wilde,
National President
 

Top of Page

SECRETARY'S REPORT

Following the election of the current committee at the AGM in November 1998, materials were sent to Jennie Shaw and myself by Peter Campbell and Jaki Kane in January and February 1999. The first initiative implemented by the new executive was the establishment of an e-mail newsgroup keeping National Committee members updated on the executive's activities by distributing minutes and feedback. The first of these went out on 23rd February, and as of September 1999 some 10 had already been sent.


However, laying to rest concerns raised following the 1998 AGM, the geographical split of the executive between Adelaide and Melbourne has caused no problems whatsoever. During the first half of 1999 alone, the executive held five teleconferences and met in person on one occasion as well. While Jennie Shaw, and later (following Jennie's departure for Japan) Jula Szuster and I have maintained the day-to-day task of running the Society, Craig De Wilde has been kept in constant touch about via e-mail and assisted with support and advice. Together with Daniela Kaleva, who has kindly agreed to take on the new role of Membership Secretary, Craig was also kind enough to shoulder the onerous task of mailouts to members. Thanks also go in this respect to Chris Wainwright and Jula Szuster with their help in the mailout of 1999 membership renewals.


As this executive's other initiatives, such as the design of a new membership brochure and the expansion of the Society's website, will be dealt with in subsequent reports at this AGM, and as the developments have also been covered, and will be covered, in the Newsletters, I will limit my comments here to the customary secretarial domain of membership administration.


Individual memberships
Tables 1.1 and 2 (see p. 16) give, respectively, a view of our current membership break-down and the figures for the last seven years. Since November 1998, and as of 9 September 1999, MSA received 28 new members, a particularly spectacular upsurge in WA membership accounting for over half. All transactions with the executive now attract receipts; new members receive an introductory letter, explaining the membership period, what they can expect to receive as members, the Annotated membership list, and copies of recent mailings and latest Newsletter. Renewals notices for membership year 1999 (our membership year currently begins from June 1) were sent in May using a new form which gave members opportunity to back order the journal, make updates of the Annotated Membership list data, as well as information on the new website. As of late May 1999, when renewals were sent, some 67 members remained unfinancial for 1998. Also, a number of members, from payment dates on file, were obviously paying for each year as payment for the next became due. MSA policy having been to withhold copies of the journal until members actually paid for that year, overdue members were given the opportunity to renew for 1999 and back order MA 21 for $40, hence saving them $10 on renewal for both years. Within a month of sending the notices over a third of our gross individual members (i.e. both 1998 and pre-1998), had already renewed, but, as 9 September 1999, some 116 members remain unfinancial. Members stay on our books for 16 months following their membership period, so those not having renewed by November 1999 (currently 27) will be deleted at that time.


At the 1998 AGM a motion was passed requesting the Society institute multiple-year subscriptions with some sort of savings being involved. The matter was given considerable thought by the executive, and was decided against at this stage. Even a minimal cost saving to members taking up such an offer would have substantially depleted our income on a longer-term basis. There is, of course, nothing to stop members paying for more than year if they so wish (a very few do so already); our main concern was the loss of revenue incurred in proposing a discount, and the added complications involved in chasing member-ships and changes of address.


Chapters
The executive has also established closer contact with chapter secretaries or representatives and sending both lists of members' addresses regular updates as members join within particular states. In this way state chapters can keep their own mailing lists up to date. Quarterly payments of membership and other dividends to the State Chapters have also been re-established.


It should also be pointed out that there is little the national body can do to attract members, apart from facilitating administration and assisting chapters and conference convenors wherever possible. It is also policy of the MSA to require that persons giving papers at our events be current financial members at the time, a policy enforced (if that is the word) at both 1998 and 1999 conferences, and which did ensure a number of renewals and applications. But it remains the responsibility of chapter executives to ensure that membership within their particular jurisdiction is carefully nurtured. Inactive chapters tend to have lower renewal rates.
An important initiative was also launched in regard to the activities of the Society's Chapter's this year, a motion being passed at the National Committee meeting in Perth inviting chapters to apply to MSA national for one-off grants to assist them with special projects and initiatives. I would remind all chapter executives of this provision and warmly encourage applications.


Institutional memberships
I am greatly indebted here to Jennie Shaw for her assistance in initially working through the files. As can be seen from Table 1.2, the MSA deals here with over 150 'institutional members', effectively journal subscribers, including about 16 subscriber agencies which either receive both invoices and the mailings, or only pay invoices while journals are dispatched separately to their clients.


For those familiar with these tables from past secretaries' reports, I should add that I have deleted from Table 2 the old category of 'institutional members' which constituted a much smaller number that the current figures for journal distribution. Last year the latter group were renamed 'institutional members', subsuming those institutions formerly on our books as 'members' of the Society.


The administration of our institutional membership is not exactly straight forward. Some subscribers or their agencies pay pro forma, some in advance of publication, some after publication, most of their invoices specify subscription for periods completely at odds with the MSA's membership year, some receive discount as agencies and show the correct amount, others appear not to have updated our price rises, some appear to have been informed about receipt of the Newsletter, some not, and so on. As an added complication, institutional members sometimes cancel their direct subscriptions with us but continue with agencies, or (worst of all) transfer agencies. There are two firms named Blackwells, three named Ebsco, and two named Faxon. A major complicating factor is that MA currently appears some months after the end of the year specified in its issue number, so that some clients believe they are paying for a 1998 volume which could be either the volume for 1997, released 1998, or the 1998 volume, which, in June 1999, has just been released. So where payments are received, it is not always clear precisely for which volume payment is intended. While sufficient correspondence had been covered by late May to ensure we were reasonably up to date with our subscriber list before the journals were sent out, the best way, we felt, was to send more detailed invoices/dispatch notices out with all journals, as well as copies, as appropriate, to the subscriber agencies, with space provided for agencies or clients to specify their payment details, and the request the forms are returned to us, even when payments had been made. These forms, as well as requests from agencies to provide their own client lists, have gradually been returning, and are slowly helping take the guesswork out what is by far the most complex area of our business affairs. Our institutional membership remains static and quite strong, with a wide inter-national distribution over North America, the UK, Europe and as far afield as Japan, Israel and India.


In closing I would like to warmly thank Jennie, Jula and Craig as members of what I believe has been an exceptionally active and productive executive team, the communicativeness and industry of our three current conference committees and convenors, as well as the many members of the national committee and wider membership who have assisted, given advice or suggestions in many useful ways, particularly Stephen Wild and Elizabeth MacKinlay for their drafting of the "Welcome to Country" statement, Anne-Marie Forbes for her work on the new brochure text, and Royston Gustavson for his assistance with constitutional issues. Last but not least I wish to thank Anita Donaldson, herself an MSA member, Dean of our hosting institution in SA, the Elder Conservatorium, School of Performing Arts, for her strong support and practical assistance.

SECRETARY’S REPORT

Table 1

Membership as at September 1999

1. Individual Membership as at September 1999

Chapter /

Category

Ordinary

Student

Emeritus

Spouse

Life

Total on books*

Paid up as of 9-9-1999

ACT

11

5

2

-

-

18

8

NNSW

6

2

-

-

-

8

4

QLD

28

14

2

1

1

46

24

SA

19

5

3

1

1

29

24

SYD

41

13

2

2

3

61

38

VIC

46

30

2

4

3

85

50

WA

17

12

-

-

1

30

20

OSEAS

18

3

-

-

1

25

16

TOTAL

186

84

11

8

10

302

184

* Members last paid for 1997 (total 31) and not since renewed have not yet been deleted from these totals.

2. Institutional Members

Total (national and international) 167* (virtually all paid up for 1998/99)

* This is the total number of copies of Musicology Australia we currently dispatch; some of our subscribers are not known to us, as in a number of cases the copies are sent to distribution agencies.

Table 2

Seven-Year Summary of Individual Membership by Chapter

(Figures, excluding those for institutional memberships, taken from 1998 report by Jaki Kane)

Chapter / Year

1993

1994

1995

1996

1997

1998

Sept 1999 (total / paid)

ACT

19

18

19

23

20

18

18 / 8

NNSW

8

7

6

3

4

6

8 / 4

QLD

41

43

51

51

49

44

46 / 24

SA

18

17

15

19

25

27

29 / 24

SYD

65

63

67

69

63

56

61 / 38

VIC

70

71

73

81

86

68

85 / 50

WA

27

27

23

17

14

16

30 / 20

OSEAS

20

20

22

24

24

20

25 / 16

TOTAL

268

266

276

287

285

255

302 / 184


John A. Phillips,
National Secretary

Top of Page

TREASURER'S REPORT

For the year ended 30 June 1999

The Musicological Society of Australia has had a successful year financially, resulting in a healthy surplus of $3,968 and thereby increasing the society's net assets to $30,382.
This was achieved despite incurring some expenses such as the increased cost of printing the newsletter and the further development of the web site. These expenses have been more than covered by increased income from membership subscriptions and the profit from the National MSA Conference held in Adelaide in November 1998.
In March 1999, the Executive decided to place $14,000 into a high interest bearing ANZ V2 Plus account. As at 30 June, the interest rate was 3.78% and the account had generated $79.62 extra income after four months.
The income generated over the twelve month period included $11,381 in subscriptions from members and institutions, which was an improvement of $771 on the previous year. The two National Conferences in Adelaide and Perth both generated increased memberships for the year and the Adelaide conference produced a profit of $2,308. The financial result from the Perth conference will not be shown until the coming financial year, but there was a similarly good result with a profit of $2,336.


Lower interest rates, however, resulted in a decrease in the total interest earned for the 1998/99 financial year: $401 as compared to $682. The $14,000 deposited in the V2 Plus account had only 4 months in which to generate a better level of interest.
The most significant expenditure for the year was $2,145 for the develop-ment of the web site, the payment of two years subscriptions for both IMS and ICTM in the one year (ie. for 1998 and 1999) and the extra printing costs for the IMS bid brochure and for the annotated membership list. Cost increases where incurred with the printing and postage for the newsletter as well as $750 more for general postage. Overall costs for the journal appear to be less, however the final cost for postage of Volume 21 has yet to be invoiced and is likely to be similar to the 1997/98 figure. Administrative costs have been kept to $617, which is considerably less that the $921 incurred in the previous year.


Since 30 June 1999, there have been a significant amount of income with subscriptions from individual and institutional members: July and August have proved to be extremely busy months for membership renewals. A major distribution of membership contributions to State Chapters was undertaken in early August. There are a number of expenses, however, that are expected soon. The new brochure has cost $1,412, a further $2,000-$3,000 has been earmarked for the further development of the web site and the audit process for the 1998/99 accounts has cost the society $425.
There were three treasurers for the 1998/99 financial year. Jenny Shaw replaced Peter Campbell at the AGM in Adelaide in November 1998, and I replaced Jenny when she moved to Japan in March 1999. As the third incumbent I would like to thank both Peter and Jenny for their exemplary work in keeping the accounts in such good order and making my job of reconciling the accounts such an easy process. I feel that the society has been well served by these fine, orderly minds and I would like to thank them both for the work that they have done.


I would also like to thank the National MSA Committee for their support throughout the year, and my special thanks go to the Executive, Craig and John, for their hard work on behalf of the society. It has been my pleasure to work with such a dedicated team.
Jula Szuster

MUSICOLOGICAL SOCIETY OF AUSTRALIA
TREASURER'S REPORT
1 JULY 1998 TO 30 JUNE 1999

BALANCE

Carry Forward as at 1 July 1998

$21,758.39

Transfer to V2

14,000

7,758.39

INCOME
Subs

11,733.52

Journal

3,868.12

Interest

126.07

Adelaide Conference Profit

2,308.04

Other (include Insurance)

961

TOTAL INCOME

18,996.75

EXPENDITURE
Bank Charges

140.14

Newsletter

732.84

Journal

5,026.55

Postage

2,740.95

Web Site Development

2,144.90

Administration

399.81

Subscriptions

534.39

Distribution to Chapters

1,788.64

Misc

1,190.75

TOTAL EXPENDITURE

INCOME-EXPENDITURE

14,699.07

 

$12,056.07

as at 30 June 1999

Comments

1. $14,000 transferred to VC account. Current interest rate 3.8% 2. Subscriptions. Since renewal notices sent, 103 individual membership subscriptions have been received. 3. Journals. Back issues, including Vol 21 (1998) for members whose subscriptions lapsed for 1998. 4. Administration costs. Stationery, printing, photocopying. 5. Subscriptions. 2 years (1998 & 1999) payments to IMS & ICTM 6. Distribution to Chapters. Conference profit distributed: $577.60 to SA Chapter, $97.84 each to other Chapters. Subs distribution in January 1999. Next distribution in early July. 7. Misc expenses. GIO insurance, ACT Registrar General costs, ACT P.O. Box, Printing (Annotated List & IMS Bid) Liabilities 1. New brochure (Design, Printing, Wed Site Images, postage) $1,412 2. Postage for MA Vol 21 ? 3. Audit approx. $600 4. Web Site charges, per annum approx. $500

Click here to see the Independent Audit Report

 

Top of Page

WAGGA WAGGA WEEKEND WEEKEND
Riverine Club, Wagga Wagga
11-12 September 1999
REPORT

Participants
Roland Bannister, Michael Christoforidis, Craig De Wilde, Christopher Draber, Elizabeth Kertesz, Ian McDonald, John Phillips, Jennie Shaw, Jula Szuster, Stephen Wild, Carol Williams (Sunday only: Prue Neidorf, Allan Marett).

Introduction
The focus of the society's Wagga Wagga Weekend Weekend (WWWW) was a series of three 'minimally structured' Conversations About Research. The intention was to provide time for an informal sharing of ideas, to allow all participants, no matter what their experience and expertise in musicology, to take part in an open discussion about matters of concern to them. At the first conversation participants described their own research experience and identified challenges arising from this work. From these challenges were drawn the topics of the second and third conversations.
Formal resolutions were not planned as outcomes of the meeting, though in the event, several recommendations were framed for referral to the Annual General Meeting or to future conference organisers.
This then, is a report of an ongoing discussion which occupied some seven hours; it must be read as my perception of what was said and what was meant, by the various conversationalists. Although six participants contributed short written statements, or suggested amendments, to this report, it is essentially my version of what happened.
Recreational or social events during the WWWW were: a) the street parade of the Wagga Wagga Jazz Festival, b) a guided tour of the historic Riverine Club, c) a dinner at the Wagga Wagga Commercial Club, and d) a visit to the Red Lion Hotel to hear Pete Cornelius and the DeVilles, "Tasmania's foremost blues band". The Opening Ceremony included a) a brief welcome from Local Organiser, Roland Bannister, b) a welcome on behalf of the local indigenous community by Isabel Reid, an Elder of the Wiradjuri people, c) a display of indigenous dance by The Dindima Dancer (Dane Simpson and Eddie Whyman), and d) a formal opening of WWWW by Major Patrick Pickett, Officer Commanding / Music Director of the Australian Army Band Kapooka, Director of Riverina Conservatorium of Music, and Wagga Wagga Citizen of the Year, 1999.

The Conversations

Topic: Specialisation vs. more general approaches to being a musicologist / research fashions.

It was noted that the trend in musicology is to more general approaches. Musicologists might cultivate a specialisation but this needs to be supported by a good general understanding of music if one is to obtain work as a musicologist in teaching or research. It was the impression of participants that the ARC is currently not funding unfashionable topics such as positivistic musicology. Rather, money seems to be going into studies in music and gender (but we may be seeing a decline in funding here in recent times), cultural interpretation (especially interpretations from new perspectives), aboriginal studies, and com-munity music studies. While participants were generally happy with the present trend, given the work still needed to catalogue Australian music (for example) it would be a shame if ARC funding were directed away from 'positivistic' projects altogether.

Topic: The green paper New Knowledge, New Opportunities.

It was noted that the Minister for Education, Training and Youth Affairs' green paper New Knowledge, New Opportunities proposes a change from peer review to institutional selection of research projects. How could musicologists ensure that their voice is heard in this new process? The fear was expressed that under the new system students will take up scholarships at small universities and then transfer to one of the 'big eight' universities, thus using the small universities as a convenience and causing their research profiles to decline.
Casualisation of the work force, and the intensification of work, were mentioned as two of a number of pressures against research.

Topic: How to attract students to musicology?

Solutions included the linking of music to one of the music related professions. Music librarianship, music teaching and music management programs were cited.
There is a need to structure courses in Australia in such a way as to ensure that the presence of music as a humanity is felt. We need to develop a culture which values scholarship, as well as performance.
There was a general feeling that we need to be careful of arguments that performance is research, particularly given the trend of universities to hire 'performer-researchers'. These arguments are usually made so that research dollars will be allocated to performance. Researchers need to protect research as research. Performers are able to seek funding from bodies explicitly set up to fund performance.

Topic: How might musicology best present itself to the Australian Research Council? While the area of art has several categories, music research is currently subsumed under the generic heading of music.

Alarm was expressed at the news that the University of Queensland may have plans to preclude the appointment of any Australian to its soon-to-be-advertised professorial position. This alarm had several foci: i) there should not be any covert agenda, and ii) the position should be open to an Australian, especially as the University has a long and laudable record in Australian music scholarship. The possibility of the MSA making a representation to the University to support an open, transparent appointment system, and the value of continuing the tradition of research in Australian music was discussed.
It was recommended that the MSA should write to the University of Queensland noting the University's fine record in Australian music research, with a request that this record should be continued. Mention should be made of the two previous occupants of the chair and their fine records in Australian and International Music Research.
It was suggested that the MSA might be able to promulgate this (and other) jobs on its web site. This led to the thought that profiles of prominent musicologists ought to be published in the Newsletter.

Topic: Technology, teaching, and research.

With the increased emphasis on technology there is pressure on academics to spend time on learning to use new technology. This comes at a time when there is little time to spend on such a task. Should money be spent on employing outsiders to do the technological side of the musicologist's work, or should provision be made to provide time for academics to learn to use technology? Or should the status quo persist in which academics just have to fit the mastering of technology into already full schedules? Discussion on just how far the technology push may go led to the question: Will we proceed as far as complete off-campus on-line teaching?
Problems of copyright in the on-line environment were discussed. Speakers identified problems in obtaining copyright to recorded material for on-line reproduction. Increased ease of access to sound has created a nightmare of copyright problems.
Another problem is for scholars to study only that which is 'available' on-line, rather than go to concrete or 'real' sites to study material in situ. There is value in on-line manuscripts, for instance, as they allow us to seek out original material and to develop questions about it before we go to real sites, which of course may be in places geographically remote from the researcher.

Topic: What role should the MSA play in the electronic distribution of material?

Should the MSA apply for funding for a data base of on-line material? Or is NFRAM addressing this question? Should the MSA list theses and/or abstracts on its site? With a possibility to download?
Manuscripts, contents lists, back issues of publications, conference / seminar programs, abstracts, and papers were all possible material for distribution on the site. Book reviews, additional to those appearing in Musicology Australia (MA) could be published on the web. There was agreement that we need to convey to a broad audience just what it is that our graduate students are doing. There was agreement that conference title and abstracts should appear on the web site, prior to the conference.
There was a potential problem that on-line material on the MSA site could be seen to have MSA endorsement. Or would our disclaimer, already on the site, distance the MSA from contributors' views? Or, would our audience understand that listing does not necessarily mean endorsement?
The question of commercial possibilities was discussed. Should the MSA offer research materials for sale? In hard copy? What then would be the commercial relationship between the MSA and the author? There was agreement that the site should be a 'front window'. People would see a title or an abstract, and then decide to buy the item. the MSA could then act as a broker, either on a profit or non-profit basis.
MSA would be able to provide funding to train a web-site coordinator, rather than to employ an outsider: it is important that this be a subsidy for training, not a direct payment.

Topic: Insufficient papers of publishable quality are being submitted to Context and to MA, and there is a need to improve the quality of papers at MSA conferences.

Central to this topic was the question of quality vs. inclusiveness. The value of a separate program committee vs. the local committee having programming responsibility was discussed. Arguments were put that a separate program committee (like that practised by ICTM) could ensure higher quality papers. In this model, the national committee would determine the theme(s) and appoint the program committee which would be drawn from the whole membership. Paper proposals would be sent to the chair of the program committee and selected and shaped into the conference program by the committee. The convenor of the conference would be a member of the program committee as well as being chair of the local organising committee, and the link between the two. One view was that only local committees can have an overall conception of their conference and its programming, and thus programming should be a local committee responsibility. There was agreement that a better quality of paper is desirable, and the programming procedure will vary from situation to situation, but local committees will not feel comfortable if they do not have a big say in what gets heard.
The view was expressed that conferences were the most important activity of the MSA, and that there were several problems which needed attention to improve their value. There was an opinion that papers which were not up to a presentation standard would be better presented as poster sessions or in round tables. This led a to a long discussion about the need for a greater degree of interaction between scholars at conferences. The opportunity to spend a longer time in discussion, like that at the American Musicological Society meetings, and like that being experienced here at the WWWW was most desirable. The prospect of discussion, unfettered by time constraints, would encourage presenters to think about the wider implications of what they had to say, and especially to think about how their content or argument related to the conference theme. The need for at least ten minutes of discussion time was emphasised. Round tables, study groups, and conversations were all put forward as ways in which to foster interaction, and to provide an opportunity for people with work in progress to workshop their ideas, rather than try to present their work in a formal way. The standard twenty minute paper plus ten minutes conversation too often ended up with a longer paper and little conversation. Some papers, by the nature of their content, provoke, or invite, questions. Others do not.
The group universally condemned the practice of speakers running over time, and some thought that this practice was especially odious where the speaker was a 'big name' and others felt that it was the 'big names' who were most tempted to run over time.
There should be scope for members to propose three-or-four-paper study sessions. An abstract should be provided for each of the papers as well as an abstract for the session as a whole. These sessions should reflect areas of study in Australia, and need not reflect the overall conference theme.
The role of the chairperson in conference sessions needs clarification, and the following suggestions emerged from the discussions. The chairperson
· should be appointed well in advance of the conference, and preferably have some expertise in the subject of the session;
· should be encouraged to contact the speakers before the conference, and perhaps ask for copies of their papers in advance, say a month before. This might enable the monitoring of quality/appropriateness/length of papers and would give the chairperson the opportunity to formulate questions, even to shape the session;
· should enforce the maximum length of papers, as it is vital to leave time for discussion;
· should open up the session for questions, if necessary by posing pertinent questions him or herself;
· should then also moderate the discussion and seek to keep it going. This is to avoid the discouraging effect of a paper being greeted by silence, or only one or two desultory responses.

Keynote speakers could be better used if they were to participate in interactive sessions, rather than simply present their formal address.
It was further suggested that at the Sydney conference there should be an allocation of time for the ideas discussed at WWWW to be developed. There were several reiterations of the value of this open, and prolonged, type of discussion.

Topic: Role of the MSA, especially in the musical/political/scholarship context.

This topic had been touched on from time to time in the context of other topics. While we need to participate in this political process in order to represent the views of members, our articles of incorporation precluded us from being a lobby group. Yet it was felt that advocacy, or representation, or putting ideas forward, were all perhaps different from overt 'lobbying' and may not flout the conditions of our articles.
It was suggested that the MSA have a representative on the Australian Music Council, which is constituted as a lobby group. This should be done in a formal way. There was a question about the possibility of the MSA forming links with other research organisations like literary societies, historical societies, and so on. The Australian Academy of the Humanities (AAH) could be an umbrella group under which we lobby. We particularly need to ensure that music research has a place on the ARC research categories. Perhaps the MSA could seek recognition as a nominating body for ARC. Music research should be seen as a humanity, if we are to avoid having our submissions read by music performers, or perhaps even by dancers, rather than by humanities scholars.
It was agreed that a direct representation to the ARC should be our first step, but that later we may have to go through the AAH.

Topic: A 'student perspective' on MSA conferences.

A student offered an opinion of how MSA conferences might be improved, particularly if they are to appeal to beginning researchers. The suggestions are relevant, I believe, to all of us. In summary, the student's opinion was:
Experienced presenters should be high quality role models for students in all aspects of conference presentation: research should be rigorous, writing should be clear, and presentations should be well prepared. Beginning researchers would welcome constructive criticism and encouragement from senior academics. MSA conferences can be daunting and 'cliquey' for students. It has taken four national conferences for this particular student to feel welcome as a member of the society.
As an experienced conference goer, I can say that there is a need for all of us to ensure that newcomers of any age, but particularly students, are made personally welcome. Simple things like actually talking to newcomers, and having lunch, or a glass of absinth with them, help to break down the social barriers which I expect that most of us have experienced at some point in our lives.


Roland Bannister, Convenor
With contributions from Michael Christoforidis, Christopher Draber,
Elizabeth Kertesz, Jennie Shaw, and Stephen Wild

Top of Page

ACT

Following changes to the ACT membership in recent months, a new executive was elected in Canberra last year. Jaki Kane is now president, Elizabeth Matheson secretary and Helen Saunders Treasurer. The first meeting for 2000 will be held on 9 March at 8.00 pm, at the Canberra School of Music, where Hazel Hall will talk about her visit to the Tibetan Institute of Performing Arts in Dharamsala, India. Contact for the executive is via Jaki Kane, email Jaki.Kane@anu.edu.au, or post to her at the Canberra School of Music, GPO Box 804, Canberra ACT 2601.
Jaki Kane,
President, ACT Chapter, & Ed.

Top of Page

QUEENSLAND

The second half of 1999 witnessed an eventful time for the Queensland Chapter of the MSA. On 29 July, the Chapter joined with the School of Music University of Queensland to host an evening seminar by visiting German scholar Professor Hartmut Moeller (Freiburg and Rostock). Professor Moeller presented a stimulating discussion on "Music in the two German States after World War II", which included many musical examples of contemporary compositions from these regions.
Entitled The Big Musicology Gig, the 1999 symposium was held on Sunday 5 September at the Queensland Conservatorium, Griffith University.

Ten promising young researchers from a variety of music disciplines presented papers on a broad range of topics including Thomas Tallis (Bronywn Ellis), Medieval Chant Manuscripts (Rebecca Palmer), Physiographic notation (Luke Jaaniste), Australian Aboriginal ceremony (Andrea Layt), Eco-acoustology (Kai-Wei Choong), Musicology and the media (Gavin Carfoot), the Contemp-orary performing arts in urban South Africa (Brydie Leigh-Bartlett), Contemporary church singing (Penelope Bewsher), Schubert and sonata form (Sun-ju Soong), Handel and Andrew Lloyd Webber (Andrew Bull) and Music-speech relationships in Gypsy (Tim Passmore). Our congratulations go to the winner for the best student presentation, Luke Jaaniste, whose presentation on physiographic notation was lively and extremely stimulating. Our many thanks also to the two judges, Dr John Bradley (Department of Anthropology and Sociology, The University of Queensland) and Peter Tregear (School of Music, The Uni-versity of Queensland), and all those who participated to make our last seminar for the millennium memorable.


The traditional Christmas party was kindly hosted by QLD members Colin Brumby and Jenny Dawson where the chapter bid a sad farewell to our current Chairman Anne-Marie Forbes. Anne-Marie and have her family have moved south to Tasmania where she has taken up a lectureship in musicology at the University of Tasmania. Her enthusiasm, commitment, professionalism and innovation will be missed in Queensland and we wish her and her family the very best for their future.
Our next function will be the AGM on 19 March to be held at the University of Queensland and we eagerly anticipate the year ahead.
Elizabeth Mackinlay,
Secretary, Queensland Chapter

Top of Page

SOUTH AUSTRALIA

The SA chapter continued to hold regular monthly meetings in the 2nd half of 1999, in association with the Elder Conservatorium School of Performing Arts.
On 24 August, visiting Professor Hartmut Moeller from the Musikhochschulen in Freiburg and Rostock spoke on "Abendland (The Western World) Universal Claims in German concepts of World Music". The 12 October meeting was devoted to a paper by Steven Knopoff on the Yolngu people of northeast Arnham Land, entitled "What the Song of the Tawny Frogmouth Tells Us" and Helen Rusak on "Gender Confusion in Elena Kats-Chernin's Iphis".


The final meeting of the year was dedicated to a lecture/recital by Stephen Whittington, Co-ordinator of the Performing Arts Technology Unit (PATU) at the University of Adelaide, entitled "On a Persian Carpet: The late music of Morton Feldman".
The SA Chapter has initiated a postgraduate musicology prize, in memory of Naomi Cummings who was a research assistant to Professor Andrew McCredie at the University of Adelaide in the late 1980s. (Prize details p. 48 - Ed.).
Jula Szuster,
President, SA Chapter


SYDNEY

The Graduate Music Symposium 99 was a joint venture of the NSW Chapter with the Canberra Chapter and the Graduate Music Program of the Canberra School of Music. The Graduate Music Symposium was held at the Canberra School of Music on 30-31 July 1999 and was convened by Elizabeth Brookes, David Cashman and Robyn Holmes. Papers were given by students of the Canberra School of Music, the University of New South Wales, the Sydney Conservatorium and the Music Department of the University of Sydney, the University of Western Sydney Nepean, and the University of Melbourne. Steven Wild of AIATSIS gave the Keynote Address, and Carol Williams of Monash University the Plenary Session.


Larry Sitsky addressed the conference on the subject of his new Violin Concerto. Sessions were chaired by Deborah Crisp, Greg Schiemer, Kathleen Nelson, Graham Hair and Stephen Wild. Papers were given by Liz Matheson, Alan Maddox, Sandra Baker, Kirsty Gillespie, Brad Cummings, Katia Tiutiunik, Judith Crispin-Cresswell, Ruth Lee-Martin, Katherine Barnett, David Cashman, Helen Saunders, Elizabeth Brookes, Meredith Connie, Adrian Renzo, Corrina Bonshek, Barry Kenny, Hassan Shanal, Katrina Hunt and Rachel Hainsworth. A report on the conference was published in Articulation vol. 2 no. 3 (1999). (Reprinted below, p. 32 - Ed.)


On 28 November, the Annual General Meeting was held and David Cashman stepped down as Convenor of the Sydney Chapter. A vote of thanks was given to the outgoing committee and David. The 2000 committee consists of Anne Power (Convenor), Adrian Renzo (Secretary), Terry Clinton (Treasurer and Chapter delegate to the National Conference Organising Committee), and committee Members include Barry Kenny, Sally Macarthur and Peter McCallum.
Anne Power,
Convenor, Sydney Chapter

Top of Page

VICTORIA

The most important events of the second half of 1999 were, once again, the Chapter conference and awarding of the Musicology Prize, and the AGM, both held on 29 October at Melbourne University.
The conference once again covered a wide variety of topics, including papers by Chris Draber on Brahms's chamber music; Tim Stevens on the Red Onions Jazz Band; Nina Tsitsishvili reporting on her recent fieldwork in the republic of Georgia; Sally Watt on the motets of Simonis Boyleau; Angeline Brasier on Pauline Viardot and Nancy Calo on Dom Rosendo Salvado at New Norcia. Gillian Graham won the 1999 Musicology Award for her stimulating paper on the relationship between certain aspects of Margaret Sutherland's life, partic-ularly her marriage and divorce, and perceptions of her creative output by later biographers.


The Chapter AGM was held after the luncheon break. Carol Williams presented her final report as President after long years of service to the Chapter in this role. Sue Robinson was elected as the new Chapter President, Michael Christoforidis replaced John Weretka as treasurer and Joel Crotty has taken over Sue Robinson's previous position as conference coordinator. Sue Cole and Trish Shaw both continue their current positions as secretary and newsletter editor.
The year concluded with a drinks night on 3 December. Although the numbers were small, it was a successful social conclusion to the year and it is hoped this event will become a regular part of the Chapter's social calendar.


The Chapter is looking forward to a productive year. A substantial contingent from Victoria is planning to attend the forthcoming National Conference in Sydney and proposed visits from overseas scholars, including Stephen Banfield, Roy Howat, Tim Carter and Annagret Fauser, are expected to provide a strong stimulus to musicology in Victoria.
Sue Cole,
Secretary, Victorian Chapter

Top of Page

MUSICOLOGY AUSTRALIA, VOL. 23 (2000)
A Report by the Editor

Some changes
Volume 23 will appear bearing some significant and exciting changes. First, the trim size of the journal is to change from A4 to B5. At the time of writing, a new cover is being designed, and a new text design/page layout will be com-missioned shortly.
As regards content, the various registers currently positioned at the end of the journal are to be moved to the Society's website. On the website this information will be linked to a search facility to make looking for particular topics and subjects quick and easy.
Volume 23 will also contain a series of specially commissioned review articles. These review articles are not conventional reviews in that a single score, book or monograph is dissected and critiqued. Rather, a group of books on a common subject will be discussed to see what contribution they make to the bigger picture of their area of focus. They will be similar in style to the review of books published monthly in The Australian. They are not designed to be commentaries nor are they a forum for complaint. The review article in Volume 23 examines two books (by non-musicologists) that explore Australian musical tastes, and the idea of 'expatriation' in Australian musical history.


Call for articles
More than ever, the journal needs the fruits of your labours. Musicology Australia is, increasingly, finding itself read and shelved all over the world. In the last twelve months alone, two music editors from major European publishing houses have asked to see back copies of the journal. Who knows what good might come of being 'seen' in MA! I have high hopes of (gradually) publishing more articles each year. I am actively pursuing papers, but if you would like to pursue me to consider a piece from you - I'd be glad to hear from you (my contact details appear below). Readers should be reminded that articles cannot be accepted for publication until a due process of peer review is completed.
Calling all book reviewers
Reviews are always welcome, too. For those of you that are sitting on reviews-please send them in-pronto!
For those readers who would like to review a book, the following publications have been received for review but need someone to review them. Let me know if you'd like to review any of the following and I'll dispatch them to you as soon as possible.
Abramovich-Gomon, Alla. The Nenet's song: A microcosm of a vanishing culture. (Aldershot: Ashgate, 1999)
Adorno, Theodore W. Sound Figures (trans. Rodney Livingstone). (Stanford: Stanford University Press, 1999)
Averill, Gage. A Day for the Hunter, a Day for the Prey: Popular music and power in Haiti. (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1997)
Crabtree, Phillip D. and Foster, Donald H. Sourcebook for Research in Music (first paperback edition). (Bloomington: Indian University Press, 1999)
Friedson, Steven M. Dancing prophets: Musical experience in Tumbuku healing. (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1996)
Ingham, Richard (ed.) The Cambridge Companion to the Saxophone. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1998)
Monson, Ingrid. Saying something: jazz improvisation and interaction. (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1996)
Priest, Deborah. Louis Laloy (1874-1944) on Debussy, Ravel and Stravinsky. (Aldershot: Ashgate, 1999)
Tunley, David. The Bel Canto Violin. The Life and Times of Alfredo Campoli. (Aldershot: Ashgate, 1999)
Watson, Thomas. Italian madrigal Englished (1599). Ed. and trans: Albert Chatterley. (London: Stainer and Bell, 1999)
Wykes, David. The Classical Concerto: Form and Principle. (Essex: Talkcrest, 1997)

Contact details
Paul Watt pwatt@cup.edu.au, 57 Forster Street, Heidelberg, VIC, 3081. Phone (ah): (03) 9459 1459.
Paul Watt,
Editor (incoming), Musicology Australia

Top of Page

UPDATE ON THE MSA WEBSITE

After considerable bureaucratic delays in getting our site name registered, the MSA's website was moved to its permanent address in January of this year. Please log on at: http://www.msa.org.au (please note that if you have visited the old site before, it may be necessary to refresh your browser by clicking 'Refresh', or pressing [Shift] F5).


Late last year, the executive was delighted to appoint, as Website Coordinator, Victorian member Brett Chapman. Brett comes to this role with tremendous enthusiasm coupled with many years of experience in IT, and hence required none of the expensive training we expected to have to provide! We wish him well in this task, and also extend our sincere thanks and appreciation to our retiring webmaster, Annie Leverington of Quality Essentials, who assisted us so ably in the early stages and was so persistent in the laborious process of getting our site registered.


Brett will now step-by-step undertake the upgrade of the site agreed to the Special General Meeting in Perth last year, but at far less cost to us, and we are delighted that we will now be able to benefit from his agreement to update the site far more regularly, making it possible for us to post information as it comes to hand. Numerous updates have already been done: check the 'new' link on the home page to see what has been changed since you last logged on. Brett has already finished preparing the indexes and listing of abstracts for Musicology Australia; these can now be found on the site under 'Publications'.  The registers of members' publications, and theses in music will also find their way onto the web over the course of the next few months. As Paul Watt observed in his report (above), these listings will no longer be published in MA from volume 23 onwards, thus freeing up valuable space for articles.


Until recently, the crucial task of listing our site with the major search engines was also held up by the delay in getting our domain name registered. This has now been done, however, and the site should begin appearing on searches in response to specified keywords within the next weeks. Brett has installed a hit counter so we can monitor traffic, and will continue to test the site for compatibility with all major browsers. Wherever possible, he will undertake smaller changes and updates on a 'same day' basis. He also has asked me to mention a number of initiatives and plans he would like to get up and running over time.

They include:
· Researching the possibility of a Discussion Board area. This would mean installing a page where members can ask questions (and we hope, get answers). This should be a good way to attract visitors. Brett explained he would be prepared to field technical PC questions. Active promotion in the printed copy of MA (and in this Newsletter) would be required initially, but over time it can be hoped that members will begin to see the site as a useful resource.
· Looking at contacting other similar organisations and getting each other's web sites listed (Link Exchange).

Brett pointed out that we already have the beginnings of this on the "Other Sites of Interest" area, but he would like to expand this-and make sure the other sites list MSA on their web sites!
For any questions, suggestions, updates, corrections or enquiries of any kind, please feel free to contact Brett at Brett.Chapman@riotinto.com
Ed.

Top of Page

CONFERENCE REPORTS

35TH WORLD CONFERENCE OF THE
INTERNATIONAL COUNCIL FOR TRADITIONAL MUSIC
19-25 August 1999, Hiroshima

Both in terms of the number of people who participated and the quality of papers presented, the 35th World Conference of the ICTM was a highly successful conference. Among the 270 participants were eleven Australians, eight of whom gave papers or presented panels. Stephen Wild, Allan Marett and Linda Barwick presented a well received plenary panel on Music and Reconciliation under the conference theme of Music and Peace. Their respective papers were entitled "Music, Dance and Reconciliation in Australia", "Regeneration and Reconciliation through the Performance of wangga in contemporary Australian contexts" and "Wumpurrarni songs for papulanji: producing a CD of Warumungu women's songs for an Australian and a global audience". In this panel the participants explored traditional Aboriginal modes of reconciliation as they are revealed through ceremonial and other perform-ances against the background of current debates about reconciliation in Australia. Helen Reeves Lawrence also presented a paper under the same theme entitled 'Music, Dance and Conflict in Christian Practice among Torres Strait Islanders'.


Papers on Asian topics included "Li Shutong: A Pioneer of Modern Chinese Music" (Peter Micic, Monash), "Minoru Miki's vision for Japanese Music" (Kimi Coaldrake, Adelaide) and "Transmission and Transgression in Biwa practice" (Hugh de Ferranti, Michigan/Sydney). Hugh de Ferranti also co-presented a workshop with Thomas Marshall and Fumon Yoshinori on "Satsuma Biwa and traditional music theory". Allan Marett chaired a session on gagaku that comprised papers by Gamo Mitsuko, Endo Toru and Terauchi Naoko. Bruce Koepke's (ANU) paper "Dance Traditions in Northern Afghanistan: Performance, Religion and Politics" was illustrated by some of his own brilliant film footage. Also attending the conference were Roland Bannister, Birgit Drüppel and Steven Nelson.
It is hoped that the Australian contribution will be sustained, or even increased, at the next ICTM World Conference scheduled for Rio de Janeiro in July 2001.
Allan Marett,
Chair, ICTM National Committee for Australia

Top of Page

GRADUATE MUSIC SYMPOSIUM '99

All who attended the Graduate Music Symposium 99 agreed that it provided a stimulating weekend with diverse points of view tabled. I for one enjoyed the vast territory covered, and felt that the diversity of papers presented indicated a healthy variety in viewpoints in the graduate student body.
Carol Williams, in summing up the approaches of the conference presentations, described the papers as being concerned with recent areas of musicologial exploration. In particular, it was the emphasis on 'new' or fresh approaches that she found impressive, and in comparison, the recent national MSA conference seemed less forward-looking. Williams also suggested (somewhat humorously) that perhaps this emphasis on new approaches may be an 'east coast' phenomenon, for it set the conference apart from similar occasions in Melbourne as well.


Papers that questioned the connections between ideology and musical practice were prominent, including the construction of the notion of the score (Helen Saunders, ANU), and postmodernism and authorship (Adrian Renzo, UWS). Relatively new methodologies for research were also displayed, for example, newspaper research (Elisabeth Matheson, ANU). Insights into early Australian musical history revealed it to be a vibrant place that holds much significance not just for Australian musical traditions, but possibly Western music making in general (Alan Maddox, Sydney Conservatorium).


Individual sessions ranged in topics from early music, composition studies, instrumental pedagogy, nineteenth century Australian music, popular music studies, and the broadly titled "Music and Musicology as Culture". This last session contained four very different papers, and represented a cross-section of universities participating in the conference. Barry Kenny (UNSW) in "Who Cares if Anyone Listens?" tackled some 'new musicologists' by pointing out the pitfalls (as demonstrated in particular by Susan McClary) of promoting analysis situated in social/political/sexual context whilst not being able to live up to one's own ideological position. Hassan Shanal (UWS) in "Holding On to Tradition" described the contradictions inherent in the writing down of an oral culture by paying particular attention to a Turkish music school in Australia. Katrina Hunt (ANU) in "Historical Dance and Dance Music in Australia" has embarked on a study of the recreation of medieval society (and particularly dance) through the Society for Creative Anachronism and the everyday practices revealed through lived medievalism. Rachel Hainsworth (UWS) in "Socioeconomic background in Relation to Musical Opportunity and Experience" compared the proportion of music students in tertiary institutions in relation to established reputation and urban proximity, questioning how the construction of musical identity and employment occur.


These four papers embodied the reflexive nature of recent musicological studies as displayed by the students involved in the conference. Understanding how the subjective self (or musicology) works within the discourse of music studies is a vital part of gaining perspectives on our own work, as well as the discipline itself. I shall look forward to hearing more from my colleagues in the future, and feel that the conference was a great success. I would like to thank all those involved, whether presenting, chairing, or observing, for their participation in this worthwhile event.
Meredith Connie
(Reprinted from
Articulation vol. 2, no. 3)

Top of Page

FORTHCOMING CONFERENCES

Please note that this is a draft from February 2000.

MUSIC AS CULTURAL INTERPRETATION
23rd National Conference of the Musicological Society of Australia
and 17th Annual Conference of the New Zealand Musicological Society

Thursday, April 27th to Sunday, April 30th, 2000
Department of Music, Seymour Centre, University of Sydney

Conference ThemesThe theme of the conference, Music as Cultural Interpretation, aims to include all aspects of musicological research. It is particularly intended as an invitation for musicologists to reflect on the cultural and theoretical underpinnings of their research enterprises and to consider ways in which they relate to other disciplines in the Humanities and Social Sciences for whom cultural interpretation is a major focus. Subthemes include:

  • Cultural Interpretations of Music
  • The Contribution of Musicology to the Study of Popular Music
  • Current Issues in Research in Indigenous Performance

Keynote Speakers

  • Susan McClary, University of California, Los Angeles: TEMP WORK: Music and the Cultural Shaping of Time
  • Robert Walser, University of California, Los Angeles (Paper title to be announced)
  • William Dart, Waikato University: Our Voice: Towards a Kiwi Music Vernacular

Panelists

Linda Barwick, University of Sydney

Philip Hayward, Macquarie University

Marcia Langton, Melbourne University

Djon Mundine, National Museum of Australia

Stanley Sadie, New Grove Dictionary of Music and Musicians

Convenors

Convenor: Allan Marett  Allan.Marett@music.usyd.edu.au

Deputy Convenor: Nicholas Routley Nicholas.Routley@music.usyd.edu.au

Program: Sally Macarthur s.macarthur@uws.edu.au

Secretary: Jacqui Harrison j.harrison@vcc.usyd.edu.au

Treasurer: Natalie Shea nshea@mail.usyd.edu.au

Accommodation and travel: Kathy Marsh kmarsh@mail.usyd.edu.au

Trade displays: Terry Clinton tclinton@mail.usyd.edu.au

Student contact: Sally Treloyn streloyn@yahoo.com

New Zealand Coordinator: Warren Drake w.drake@auckland.ac.nz

Accommodation

A range of accommodation is available for conference delegates.

Comfortable hotel accommodation within easy walking distance of the conference venue can be found at:

  • Centra Travelodge (Missenden Rd, Camperdown, 02 9516 1522): daily rates from $115 (room only) to $140 (bed and breakfast) per room, including parking. Rates vary according to size of room and number of occupants
  • UniLodge (Cnr Glebe Point Rd & Broadway, 02 9338 5000): daily rates from $95 per room
  • Apartment-style accommodation is available at the Oakford City West Apartments (23 Missenden Rd, Camperdown, 02 9557 6100):

1 bedroom apartments – $130 per night

2 bedroom apartments – $175 per night

Budget accommodation a short bus ride from the conference venue is provided by:

  • Glebe Youth Hostel (262 Glebe Point Rd, 02 9692 8418):

Twin rooms $25 per person (plus $3 for non-members of YHA)

Dormitory style rooms from $19 to $21 per person (plus $3 for non-members of YHA)

  • Central Youth Hostel (Pitt St, close to Central Station, 02 9281 9111):

Dormitory accommodation (4 per room) – $26 per person

  • YWCA (5 Wentworth Ave, city, 02 9264 2451):

Dormitory accommodation – $24 per person

Single room (share bathroom) – $60 per night

Twin room – $80/$115

Single ensuite rooms – $95 per night

Delegates should book accommodation directly with the relevant hotel or hostel. Early bookings are advisable.